Boating Western Australia Inc. 10 Years of service to the Western Australian Boating Public

Home
Position Statements

Mission Statement
BoatingWA is a non profit association, established for the promotion and development of safe, economic and enjoyable recreational boating through Western Australia.

BoatingWA
PO Box 1080
Claremont  6910
Western Australia


FAX and Voice
08 93353296

e-mail; secretary@boatingwa.com.au

 

Office
1
Capo D'Orlando Drive
Fremantle, Western Australia, 6160

 

 

 

    With the introduction from October 2004 of the "Strategy for Management of Sewage Discharge from
Vessels into the Marine Environment"  we need to know more about Sewage disposal, the following are some FAQ's from overseas. 
To date no MSD type I or II has been passed by the Health Department for use in W.A. Please consider carefully before committing to expensive options.

• USA Equipment Requirements

• Managing Sewage Waste in Canada

PRINCIPLE OF OPERATION of MSD TYPE II

• POLICY GUIDANCE FOR MARINE SANITATION DEVICE ACCEPTANCE

•  What is a sewage pump-out station, how does it work, and how should a broken pump-out station be reported?

A pump-out station is an apparatus that removes the sewage from a boat's sewage holding tank and discharges the sewage to a wastewater collection system.

The pump has a hose that is fitted with a nozzle. The pump-out hose nozzle is inserted into a fitting on the deck of the boat. The pump suction removes the sewage from the boat.

Broken pump-out stations can be reported by calling the toll free number 1-800-ASK-FISH. (In the USA)

•  What is a sewage dump station?

A dump station is a facility designed to accept the contents of porta-potties.

•  Why is the discharge of boat sewage a problem?

Vessel sewage is much more concentrated than domestic sewage. Vessel sewage contains biological contaminants that can be harmful to humans. The chemicals used to treat vessel sewage can also pose an environmental and health risk.

Some potential health hazards include infectious hepatitis, diarrhoea, and cholera.

A single discharge in a low flushing environment such as a marina can be detected for at least one square mile.

Sewage acts as a fertilizer in the marine environment, leading to uncontrolled algae growth and subsequent depletion of dissolved oxygen. Low levels of dissolved oxygen can lead to the death of fish and valuable marine plant life.

Shellfish beds, swimming areas and fishing areas may be closed because of sewage contamination.

•  What is gray water?

Gray water is the water that is produced during bathing and in the galley.

•  What is the Clean Vessel Act?

US Congress passed the Clean Vessel Act (CVA) in 1992 to help reduce overboard sewage discharge by recreational boaters. The CVA provides funds to states for the renovation, construction and maintenance of pump-out stations and dump-stations. The CVA allocates portions of the grant money for education programs in the states receiving funds. 

•  How much is a marina permitted to charge for a pump-out with a CVA funded pump-out station?

A marina that has installed a pump-out station using CVA funds may charge no more than $5.00 to pump-out a sewage holding tank.

•  What is a Marine Sanitation Device?

A marine sanitation device is required on all boats with onboard toilets. It treats and discharges or stores the vessel's sewage.

•  What are the different types of marine sanitation devices (MSD's)?

Type I - Treats sewage before discharging by macerating or chopping the solids and then adding chemicals. Must meet specific standards concerning bacteria content and may show no visible solids.

Type II - Provides a higher level of treatment than a type I MSD. Treats sewage biologically and separates the solids for pump-out or incineration.

Holding Tank - A holding tank does not allow for the discharge of sewage. The waste is contained until it can be properly disposed of at a sewage pump-out station. Holding tanks are fitted with a Y - valve which allows for the direct discharge of the contents when offshore the 3 nautical mile regulation.

Details of Marine Sanitation Devices

Sewage Treatment Device Vessel Length Standard
Type I- Flow-through device (maceration and disinfection) equal to or less than 65 feet in length The effluent produced must not have a faecal coliform bacteria count greater than 1000 per 100 millilitres and have no visible floating solids.
Type II- Flow-through device (maceration and disinfection) greater than 65 feet in length The effluent produced must not have a faecal coliform bacteria count greater than 200 per 100 millilitres and suspended solids not greater than 150 milligrams per litre .
Type III- Holding tank any length This MSD is designed to prevent the overboard discharge of treated or untreated sewage.
bulletType I MSDs rely on maceration and disinfection for treatment of the waste prior to its discharge into the water.
bulletType II MSDs are similar to the Type I; however, the Type II devices provide an advanced form of the same type of treatment and discharge wastes with lower faecal coliform counts and reduced suspended solids.
bulletType III MSDs are commonly called holding tanks because the sewage flushed from the marine head is deposited into a tank containing deodorizers and other chemicals. The contents of the holding tank are stored until it can be properly disposed of at a shore-side pumpout facility. (Type III MSDs can be equipped with a discharge option, usually called a Y-valve, which allows the boater to direct the sewage from the head either into the holding tank or directly overboard. 
Discharging the contents directly overboard is legal only outside the U.S. territorial waters which is 3 or more miles from shore.)

 

 

 

 

USA Equipment Requirements - Marine Sanitation Devices

All recreational boats with installed toilet facilities must have an operable marine sanitation device (MSD) on board. Vessels 65 feet and under may use a Type I, II or III MSD. Vessels over 65 feet must install a Type II or III MSD. All installed MSDs must be Coast Guard certified. Coast Guard certified devices are so labelled, except for some holding tanks, which are certified by definition under the regulations.

When operating a vessel on a body of water where the discharge of treated or untreated sewage is prohibited the operator must secure the device in a manner which prevents any discharge. Some acceptable methods are: padlocking overboard discharge valves in the closed position, using non releasable wire tie to hold overboard discharge valves in the closed position, closing overboard discharge values and removing the handle, locking the door, with padlock or keylock, to the space enclosing the toilets (for Type I and Type II only.)

US Environmental Protection Agency's Ocean and Coastal Protection Division

Ship

US Federal Register Document, January, 1998
Marine Sanitation Device Standard--Establishment of Drinking Water Inake No Discharge Zone(s) Under Section 312(f)(4)(B) of the Clean Water Act; Final Rule.

As of January 30, 1980, if a vessel has an installed toilet (technically referred to as a marine sanitation device (MSD)), it must be equipped with one of three types of MSDs

 The MSDs (Type I, Type II, Type III) are designed to meet different needs and effluent level requirements. Since portable toilets can be moved on and off a vessel, they are not considered installed toilets; therefore, vessels that have portable toilets are not subject to the MSD regulations.


 

 

 

Managing Sewage Waste in Canada

Heads or Marine Sanitation Devices
There are currently five systems for dealing with sewage on recreational and small fishing vessels.

Marine Sanitation Devices - (MSD) Type I
bulletThis system breaks up the sewage and disinfects it with chemicals, then discharges the treated sewage overboard. Note: there, are growing concerns about the environmental effects of the chemicals used in these devices.

Marine Sanitation Device - (MSD) Type II.
bulletThis is a more sophisticated and more expensive system than Type 1. It treats the raw sewage to a higher degree through maceration and biological decomposition.

Marine Sanitation Device - (MSD) Type III.
bulletThis is a system with a holding tank that can store untreated sewage until you can dispose of it properly at a pump-out station. It is acceptable to add deodorizers. Installation cost for a holding tank is usually less than $1500.

Portable self-contained toilet.
bulletIf your boat doesn't have an installed toilet, you should consider using a portable one, commonly referred to as a "port-a-potty". It should be emptied at a pump-out station or proper disposal site.

Over the side.
bulletIf your boat discharges sewage directly overboard, you are required to comply with local pollution prevention regulations which may prohibit the use of a toilet in restricted waters. As a matter of common courtesy, do not use these toilet facilities while moored or while in anchorages, swimming areas, and harbours.

Holding Tanks
Holding tanks are a good idea, but they require pump-out facilities ashore. If possible, avoid disinfectants, which usually contain harsh chemicals.

Tips for Pumping Out
bulletFollow pump-out instructions
bulletIf instructions aren't posted, ask.
bulletAfter you finish pumping out, rinse water through the system.
bulletOnly pump out your holding tank.
bulletTurn off the pump when you are finished.

Taking Charge of Sewage waste
bulletUpgrade your marine sanitation devices, if required.
bulletUse your sanitation device with discretion.
bulletEncourage your marine or yacht club to install a pump-out service.
bulletEducate others about their use of marine sanitation devices.
bulletDon't pump your sewage overboard in anchorages, marinas, or swimming areas.

 

 

 

 

PRINCIPLE OF OPERATION of MSD TYPE II

TREATMENT PRINCIPLE

Type II Marine Sanitation Device is a biological aerobic (bacteria and air) sewage treatment system. Liquid and solid wastes are removed from the water by bacteria naturally contained in sewage.

consists of three treatment stages; aeration, clarification, and disinfection. In the aeration chamber (stage 1), the bacteria grow and multiply using the sewage as their food supply. This action reduces the quantity and size of the solid matter. In the clarification chamber (stage 2), the bacterial floc is separated from the treated solid matter. The treated water is clear and free from solids, however, the liquid must be disinfected prior to discharge overboard to kill any disease-causing bacteria. Disinfection is accomplished in the clarification chamber (stage 3).

Flow through these three stages is caused by direct displacement. When new sewage flows into the aeration chamber, an equal volume flows through the clarification chamber. This volume, in turn, displaces an equal volume from the clarification chamber into the disinfection chamber, and overboard. No internal sewage pumps are necessary.

AERATION

Sewage is aerated as soon as it enters the treatment system, and mixes with the aeration liquid already in the aeration chamber. Plastic non-clog diffusers inject air near the bottom of the aeration chamber so that the sewage remains in a state of aerobic decomposition. This aerated liquid contains the bacterial sludge that reacts with the sewage to start the reduction process. The movement created by the injected air helps mix the sewage with the bacterial sludge and prevents sludge and sewage solids from settling to the bottom. The air discharged from the surface of the liquid in the aeration chamber is vented to the atmosphere through a vent line connection.

CLARIFICATION

The liquid displaced from the aeration chamber flows into the clarification chamber for further treatment. Some of the suspended material will settle out into the chamber below, where it will be returned to the aeration chamber. The remaining sludge and waste material is removed as the liquid flows upwards through the biological filter media. Bacteria grow on the surface of the media and produce a sticky, slimy film that traps small particles of waste. The trapped waste is then consumed by the bacteria on the surface of the filter media. By the time the liquid reaches the top of the biological filter, it has passed by several layers of bacteria, ensuring that the sludge and waste removal process is completed. Clear water accumulates here until it is displaced into the discharge line, and the disinfection chamber.

DISINFECTION

The water flowing out the discharge line of the clarification chamber is collected in the disinfection chamber (chlorine contact chamber), where disinfecting chlorine tablets are located. In this chamber, the water mixes with the disinfectant for a residence time sufficient to complete the disinfection stage of the treatment process.

DISCHARGE

The clear disinfected waste water is then discharged overboard, or sent to a holding tank (for use in No Discharge Zones) for later discharge. When directly discharged overboard, the disinfected waste water flows from the disinfection chamber through a gravity discharge connection to overboard. If desired, the treated liquid can be retained in a holding tank, for later discharge, when the system is used as a Type III unit.

 

 

 

 

POLICY GUIDANCE FOR MARINE SANITATION DEVICE ACCEPTANCE

Commandant
United States Coast Guard
2100 Second Street, S. W.
Washington, DC 20593-0001
Staff Symbol: G-MSE-3
Phone: (202) 267-2206
FAX: (202) 267-4816

                                                                                                                                  16714/159.015                                                                                                                                     January 6, 1999

To: Manufacturers of Marine Sanitation Devices

 

The International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships, 1973, as modified by the Protocol of 1978 (MARPOL 73/78), requires ships to be fitted with certain pollution prevention equipment which is designed based on the performance and test specifications of a number of International Maritime Organization (IMO) resolutions. A Marine Sanitation Device (MSD) is issued an IMO Certificate of Type Test if it complies with IMO resolution MEPC.2(VI), Recommendation on International Effluent Standards and Guidelines for Performance Tests for Sewage Treatment Plants. A MSD is issued a letter of certification if it complies with United States Coast Guard (USCG) regulations.

A vessel operating in U. S. waters is not required to have a USCG accepted MSD if the vessel is not under U. S. registry. We will accept foreign flag vessels that have installed MSDs with a Certificate of Type Test indicating compliance with the requirements of MEPC.2(VI). The Certificate of Type Test must be issued by or on behalf of a government which is party to the MARPOL convention. A device meeting the testing requirements of MEPC.2(VI) will be considered as equivalent to a Coast Guard certified Type II MSD as long as the unit is in good and serviceable condition. However, such a device shall not be marked as USCG accepted based upon its compliance with MEPC.2(VI). It is only necessary to submit a MSD for review by the USCG if the device is intended for installation onboard a U. S. registered vessel.

The USCG is responsible for certification of MSDs used on U. S. registered vessels operating in U. S. waters. In order to receive USCG acceptance for installation on these vessels, a MSD must comply with the design and testing criteria of Title 33, Code of Federal Regulations (CFR), Part 159. The device shall be tested at an independent laboratory that complies with 46 CFR 159.010. The USCG maintains a listing of accepted laboratories, however, the manufacturer may request any independent facility to submit an application to the USCG for acceptance to perform testing.

A MSD complying with 33 CFR 159 is accepted for manufacture and installation onboard U. S. uninspected vessels. If, in addition to 33 CFR, Part 159, the MSD is also designed and constructed to comply with the applicable USCG marine engineering and electrical regulations, 46 CFR, Subchapters F and J, it will be accepted for manufacture and installation on U. S. inspected vessels. A USCG accepted MSD manufacturer receives a letter of certification, not a Certificate of Type Test. In addition, each USCG accepted MSD shall be marked as certified with the information as prescribed by 33 CFR 159.55.

The United States has not ratified Annex IV of MARPOL, Regulations for the Prevention of Pollution by Sewage, however, the USCG will, for U. S. manufacturers of MSDs, issue a Certificate of Type Test on behalf of IMO in accordance with MEPC.2(VI). Again, all testing must be performed by a USCG accepted independent laboratory.

After USCG review and approval, each accepted MSD model is designated a unique approval number. The approval number issued to each model is normally valid for 5 years and is recorded on the IMO Certificate of Type Test or in the letter of certification. If the manufacturer ceases to manufacture an accepted device, USCG acceptance will be withdrawn. The expiration date on the Certificate of Type Test or a letter of certification applies only to the manufacturer, not to the equipment. A MSD manufactured following the expiration date is not USCG accepted. However, devices manufactured within the valid acceptance period may be used onboard vessels as long as they are designed to comply with current environmental standards and are in good and serviceable condition.

                                                                                                       Sincerely,

                                                                                                         P. A. RICHARDSON
                                                                                                         Captain, U. S. Coast Guard
                                                                                                         Chief, Systems Engineering Division
                                                                                                         Office of Design and Engineering Standards
                                                                                                          By direction of the Commandant

 

CHAPTER I--COAST GUARD, DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

PART 159--MARINE SANITATION DEVICES Link to US Coast Guard's detailed policy's.

 


 

Copyright Notice